Wednesday, June 28, 2017

JMT series, part 4b-2 (simple rising lines)

Next is Liszt, Gnomenreigen (1863), about which I noted that "^7 [is] strikingly extended." A plausible observation if one is just considering score in hand, but not if one is listening to a performance, where notes, bars, and phrases fly by. I find this performance by Vestard Shimkus striking -- relatively slow in the main theme, but rushing by in the usual manner in the secondary theme, it is particularly expressive and "gnomish": link.

Here is a brief narrative of the design:  An introduction precedes the 16-bar main theme (A):

An abrupt shift to the secondary theme (B), in the relative major key "giocoso" -- it leads back to the introduction a complete reprise of A.



Then B returns, but now a half-step higher, in Bb major--a major third away from F# minor and a distant tonal relationship. This leads eventually to its own relative minor, G minor, and what I have called "C" but which is really a distorted variant of A.


Using a traditional device, where G minor: V7 becomes F# minor: +6 Liszt returns to F# minor but the harmony is unstable (over V).


The B theme returns one last time, now in F# major,
from which moves the (relatively) slow ascent to the structural cadence. A coda (not shown) reminds us of the figures and repeated notes of C.


An overview of the formal elements and harmony:


The ascent is overly simplified in this figure. Here are more details:
I am not overly pleased with the way that the long ascending line from A#5 to E#6 is split at C#6, but that disruption of a line is very common in Schenkerian analysis, and -- as here -- at the point where the foreground passes into the middleground or a middleground 2 to middleground 1.